Open Chat: 2007 Awards
By Rich Lederer
The 2007 award winners will begin to be announced starting today with the NL and AL Rookies of the Year. The schedule is as follows:
Mon., 11/12: NL and AL ROY
Tues., 11/13: AL CYA
Thur., 11/14: NL CYA
Mon., 11/19: AL MVP
Tues., 11/20: NL MVP
Who do you believe *should* win each of the above awards (as opposed to who you think *will* win)?
Comments
ROY:
Should win: Delmon Young, Ryan Braun
Will Win: Dustin Pedroia, Ryan Braun
Posted by: Paul at November 12, 2007 10:34 AM
ROY:
Should win: Dustin Pedroia, Troy Tulowitzski
Will win: Dustin Pedroia, Ryan Braun
Posted by: Blastings! at November 12, 2007 10:50 AM
Delmon Young? He was one of the worst every day players in 2007 -- below replacement level.
ROY:
AL - Pedroia, with Guthrie a close second.
NL - Tulo, with Braun behind Pence and a few others.
CY:
AL - Sabathia, based on an innings advantage. Beckett's second and Bedard deserves more votes than he'll receive.
NL - Peavy. Webb's in the discussion, though.
MVP:
AL - ARod. Granderson, Pena, and Posada will be under-supported.
NL - David Wright or Albert Pujols. Utley and Chipper are top five and Bonds is in the top 10. If Fielder and Howard receive any votes, it's too many.
MOY:
Don't care.
Posted by: Sky at November 12, 2007 12:00 PM
I find it to be pretty insulting that people are still somehow overlooking Pedroia. And some baseball writers didn't give him a first place vote? Seriously, these people either don't know baseball well enough or are way too over their heads in Red Sox hate.
Posted by: Peter at November 12, 2007 1:54 PM
Peter.
One can never hate the Red Sox enough.
Regardless: Pedroia and Tulowitski.
Posted by: Robert at November 12, 2007 4:24 PM
NL MVP- Holliday
AL MVP- Rodriguez
AL ROY- Okajima
NL ROY- Braun
NL CY- Peavy
AL CY- Sabathia
Posted by: Cj at November 12, 2007 5:31 PM
ROY: Tulowitzki, Pedroia
MVP: A-Rod, Rollins
CYA: Sabbathia, Peavy
(Should Wins, I think Holliday will win because the writers tend to be bigots power-wise)
Posted by: ken at November 12, 2007 5:51 PM
NL MVP - David Wright - Its not his fault his teammates couldn't get anyone out in September. He was just a much better player than either Holliday or Rollins this season; hence, he was more valuable.
AL MVP - Alex Rodriguez - If he's not a unanimous choice, it will be a disgrace (but I wouldn't be totally surprised).
AL ROY - Dustin Pedroia - Close call over Guthrie, who was somehow shut out in the actual voting.
NL ROY - Troy Tulowitzki - But only by a hair over Braun, so I'm not too upset.
NL CY - Jake Peavy - See MVP, AL.
AL CY - C.C. Sabathia - Edge in innings is too much for Carmona and Lackey (his closest competitors) to overcome.
Posted by: Bryan at November 12, 2007 6:39 PM
I agree with Sky, except for including Webb in the discussion. Although I will say, I think Okajima deserves a lot more ROY consideration than he's getting. I usually argue for WPA as a measure of these awards, but regardless of his total, he was a huge help to the Sox pen this year. Papelbon was a question mark in terms of how he'd hold up, and if it weren't for Okajima, we'd have had Piniero or Timlin closing games when Papelbon needed a rest. I really don't like either of those options. Okie stepped in wherever needed, pitched til his arm hung lifeless next to him, and baffled hitters the whole time. What a treat to watch.
Posted by: Mike at November 13, 2007 5:37 AM
Congrats to CC!
Posted by: William Austad at November 13, 2007 6:18 PM
I think you have to consider Webb. He should get a few votes at the very least. He won last year, and this year he pitched better than last year. He had a 42 inning streak of scoreless baseball. He failed to win 20+ games, mainly because of the lack of offense on the D-backs, but wins are more of a team stat than an individual stat. I'm not saying that Webb should win, but to not consider him as a candidate would be wrong.
Posted by: Brian at November 14, 2007 4:03 AM
Webb did get a few votes, second place votes, which is where he should have been. I'm glad Harangatang at least got some love this year, look for him to take the 2008 Award.
G Man
Posted by: G Man at November 16, 2007 8:51 AM